If you’ve tried dating in Toronto post pandemic times, there’s a chance you’ve also felt that the date felt more like anxiously going over a checklist instead of anxiously having a conversation. Swiping, matching, messaging, everything is performed in expectation, not curiosity. Encounters rarely feel surprising or energizing; more often, they leave you feeling empty, like you just a 1:1 meeting.
Toronto is different. Not worse than other places, just… stale. In other cities in other countries, connections can feel immediate, even accidental because in other locations where our style of multiculturalism isn’t as prevalent, shared experiences are more common than shared social media posts or trending interests. These places often allow for more organic connections due to cultural context, shared values, and the subtle interplay of lived experience which transforms encounters from transactional to meaningful.
Toronto, by contrast, offers something that feels carefully curated yet strangely hollow. It often feels like people are operating according to invisible scripts, influenced by what’s popular on social media, what’s “desirable,” what gets the most engagement, because there is no one deep-rooted culture to ground everyone.
The Algorithm Shapes the Room
Apps like Bumble and Hinge make the experience more frustrating. It’s not just that swiping is tedious, it’s that the people you actually might connect with are hidden by those who tick the algorithmic boxes. The system prioritizes extremes: models and influencers on one end, profiles that signal resignation on the other. Rarely do the “balanced,” nuanced people appear (the ones who enjoy life socially, intellectually, and emotionally, without performing either extreme).
You might recognize this now when thinking about your swiping experiences: profiles that are either all ambition and curated perfection, dead profiles with 10 year old photos and one word prompt answers of people who’ve basically given up and don’t care, or those who are sweet but present an overly eager desire for a relationship instead of highlighting any relatable interests or desirable traits about themselves. There’s very little representation of those in between all these extremes.
This mirrors a broader cultural phenomenon. Idealized behaviours such as frequent gym visits, curated entrepreneurial narratives, or social-media-friendly lifestyles, have taken over not just dating culture, but Millennial and Gen Z lifestyles as whole. And those uninterested in such performances often find themselves filtered out, invisible to those with whom they might otherwise form genuine connections.
Where Are the Balanced People?
The ones who enjoy both going out and quiet, meaningful activities. The ones who care about community, family, and friends, but aren’t obsessed with appearing “perfect” online. The ones who are fun, thoughtful, ambitious, but not exhausting. You know, humans. They exist, but they’re either hiding, married (RIP), or not being surfaced by the platforms we rely on.
It’s hard to believe meaningful encounters in Toronto are rare but possible when the majority of interactions are filtered through algorithms, social signalling, and performative culture. Recognizing that doesn’t make dating easier but it helps explain why it feels like you’re rolling through motions. And if the city is structured in such a way that meaningful encounters are neither immediate nor inevitable. The challenge lies in navigating this architecture to find your people. But what does that even mean? Where would that even take you? If you ask me, to another country 🙂